Dispatch note · 19 Nov 2026
AQL sampling: the acceptance number, the sample size and the defect you will accept
Every AQL table is an agreement about how much defect is acceptable. The number on the sheet is a decision about the customer, made by somebody in an office.

What AQL actually promises
An AQL plan does not promise a defect rate. It promises a probability of accepting a lot at a stated quality level, and a probability of rejecting a lot that is worse than that.
AQL 2.5 with a normal inspection means that a lot with 2.5 per cent defectives has a high probability of being accepted. It is a producer's risk statement, not a consumer's guarantee.
The consumer's side of the plan is the LTPD, the lot tolerance percent defective, at which there is a low probability of acceptance. That number is rarely quoted and it is usually three to five times the AQL.
A brand that writes 'AQL 2.5' and expects 2.5 per cent defect is reading the table backwards. The table's number is the quality the plan is designed to accept, not the quality the lot will have.
The sample size comes from the lot, not from the plan
The sample size code letter is a function of the lot size and the inspection level. A lot of 1,200 and a lot of 12,000 do not use the same sample, even at the same AQL.
General inspection level II is the default for most consumer goods, and level I is used when the history is good and the cost of inspection is high. Level III is used for critical products and for a first order.
The brand should state the lot size, the level and the AQL on the inspection sheet, and should check that the inspector's sample matches the letter rather than the habit.
An inspector who samples fifty pieces from every lot regardless of size is not applying the plan; they are applying a habit that happens to be right for one lot size.
Critical, major and minor are three plans
A defect classification is not a ranking of annoyance; it is a set of three separate plans with their own AQLs and their own acceptance numbers.
Critical usually means unsafe or illegal, and it is normally AQL 0 with an acceptance number of zero: one instance rejects the lot.
Major means the product does not perform its function or will not sell; minor means it performs and sells but is imperfect. The usual values are 2.5 for major and 4.0 for minor, and they should be written into the specification.
A single defect list with no classification forces the inspector to make a judgement call at the table, and judgement calls at the table are where disputes start.
The acceptance number is the whole conversation
For a given sample size, the acceptance number decides how many defects are tolerated. A plan with n=125 and Ac=7 accepts a lot with seven defects found in the sample.
The difference between Ac=7 and Ac=5 at the same sample size is a real difference in the defect rate the brand will receive, and it is not visible in the headline AQL.
The brand should compute the plan's operating characteristic curve for its own lot sizes and read the probability of acceptance at the quality level it actually wants.
A plan that accepts ninety-five per cent of lots at four per cent defect, when the brand's target is two per cent, is a plan that will deliver twice the returns it budgeted for.
Where the inspector samples from
A sample drawn from the top layer of a pallet is not a random sample of the lot. The inspector should draw from at least three cartons and from different positions in the load.
The inspection sheet should state the cartons sampled and the units per carton, so that a later dispute can be reconstructed rather than argued.
A factory that pre-selects the cartons for inspection is managing the sample, and the inspector should pick the cartons from the loading list rather than from the floor.
The sample's provenance is part of the evidence. A report without it is a report that describes a sample of unknown origin.
The defects that the table cannot see
AQL sampling inspects the product; it does not inspect the process, the material certificates or the packaging's print registration.
A lot can pass an AQL inspection and fail in the field because of a design fault that every unit shares: a connector that is too loose, a coating that fails in sunlight, a battery that degrades at forty degrees.
The brand should pair the lot inspection with a process check on the first order and a periodic reliability test on the design, because the two cover different failure modes.
A plan that inspects the output and never the process is a plan that accepts a consistently mediocre product.
Recording, escalating and the re-inspection
The inspection report should record the sample size, the acceptance number, the defects found by class and the photographs of each defect class.
A rejected lot should trigger a sorting decision: return, rework at the factory, or sort at the brand's cost. The decision and its cost should be taken before the container sails.
A re-inspection after rework should use a tightened plan, because the lot's history has changed and the plan should reflect it.
The report's value is in the year-over-year comparison: which defect classes recur, which factory improves, and which product line has a stable process. A report that is filed and never compared is a cost.
Writing the plan into the purchase order
The AQL plan belongs in the purchase order, not only in the inspection company's brief, because the factory's obligations follow the order.
The clause should state the standard, the inspection level, the AQLs by class, the acceptance numbers, the sample's source and the rework's cost allocation.
It should also state who pays for the inspection, who pays for a re-inspection, and what happens if the lot is rejected at the port of loading.
A clause with those six items converts an inspection into an agreement, and an agreement is what the brand actually needs.
The tightened plan and the history that triggers it
A tightened inspection is used when a supplier's recent lots have been rejected or when the brand's history is poor, and it uses a smaller acceptance number at a larger sample.
The switch between normal and tightened should be written in the plan: two rejects in five consecutive lots is the common trigger, and the return to normal after five accepted lots.
A brand that never switches is applying one plan to a supplier whose quality has changed in either direction.
The switch's record is the evidence that the plan is being used rather than quoted.
The inspector's independence and the factory's hospitality
An inspector who is hosted, fed and driven by the factory is in a relationship that compromises the report, even when nothing improper happens.
The brand should specify the inspector's access: unaccompanied access to the warehouse, the production floor and the records, with the factory informed but not present.
The report should include the arrival and departure times, because an inspection that lasts forty minutes for a five-thousand-unit lot did not sample the lot.
Independence is a procurement decision: a brand that selects the inspector on price alone selects for the wrong attribute.
The short version
An AQL is a probability of accepting a lot, not a promised defect rate, and the acceptance number is the number that decides what arrives.
Sample by lot size and inspection level, draw from at least three cartons, and define critical, major and minor as three separate plans.
Write the plan into the purchase order, including the sorting decision and the rework allocation, and switch to tightened inspection when the history turns.
Two final numbers
Track the defect rate by class across lots, and the share of lots that needed a tightened plan in the last quarter.
A rate that rises while the plan stays normal is a supplier drifting, and a plan that never tightens is a plan that is not being read.
The inspection desk whose report records the sample's provenance is the quality check and inspection service, and its report format is the one an AQL dispute can be settled with.
What to check
- AQL, inspection level and lot size stated on the sheet
- Critical / major / minor defined with separate acceptance numbers
- Operating characteristic curve checked against the target defect rate
- Sample drawn from at least three cartons, provenance recorded
- Process check and reliability test paired with lot inspection
- Sorting decision and cost allocation set before shipment
- Plan written into the purchase order as a clause